 |
Two options for town land:playing fields or 'eco-park'
What will town put in the pit? 4/12/01 By Rebecca Piro Andover Townsman Residents have two options regarding the fate of the Essex Sand and Gravel Pit come Town Meeting. In two weeks, some town officials will ask Town Meeting to support the construction of playing fields in the sand pit. Article 10, a town-sponsored article, proposes that the town build three multi-purpose playing fields in the pit for $1.1 million of town money, $500,000 of which the private Andover Soccer Association has promised to reimburse. Another group will hold a follow-up presentation, in favor of an ecological park, as a second option for residents. Article 11, submitted by resident Tom Jones, proposes that the town create an ecological park for plant and animal wildlife, with complete private funding. Proposals for the development of the abandoned pit has come before Town Meeting twice before, in 1995 and in 1999. Both times, residents opposed building playing fields at that location. The two opposing options are a unique situation for Town Meeting. Rarely do residents have the opportunity to choose from more than one alternative at the same Town Meeting for one piece of land. Proponents for both articles have not come together on the issue. Resident Rich Nill, Soccer association fields coordinator and supporter of Article 10 says the creation of playing fields will not harm the animals that will continue to coexist alongside the construction. "The wildlife goes there just fine with the playing fields, and very minimal habitat will be disturbed," he says. "There will be a pretty wide buffer area from the wetlands and playing fields." Nill cites the Ipswich River Park in North Reading as an example of why the playing fields scheme can please residents interested in adding to the available passive and active recreation area, as well as preserving open space and wildlife. The Ipswich River Park started four years ago as an empty gravel pit, similar to the Essex Pit, says Nill. "The town filled it in with loam and planted it with local plant species, and they have walkways and lots of park benches," he says. The park also has playing fields and other active recreation uses right next to the more protected areas. "They pretty much married the concern for the environment with their own need for playing fields in a very positive, constructive way, he adds. Considering the comparison to thc Ipswich River Park concept, Nill believes that his article is not much different from that of Jones. But Jones disagrees. He says he has nothing against the Ipswich River Park concept, which he compares to the town's Recreational Park master plan that failed more than once at previous Town Meetings. However, the wildlife that may or may not coexist alongside the proposed playing fields is not even in the same ballpark as an ecological park, he says. "It's not like there's something wrong with (the playing fields) idea," he says. "It's just that it's not this idea." The gravel pit is a protected, untouched area that does not have an already fully developed ecological space, Jones says. It can be molded and shaped into a park that shelters animals like hawks, otters, snakes and foxes, and grows medicinal herbs, plants and trees. Schools could use the park for educational field trips. "This is a place to encounter nature first-hand" says Jonesi The ecological park concept needs the pit — what he calls the "jewel" of the area-for it to work, he adds. "The gravel pit is the nucleus of what is exciting here," he says. "We'd be going from 22 to 25 soccer fields, where we'd be going from zero to one eco-parks." The playing fields option has the support of the selectmen and the Conservation Commission, which voted to recommend approval of Article 10. The Finance Committee voted to recommend approval only if the town funds the project through a debt exclusion. The fact that Jones' proposal involves no town money, especially during a time of budget crunching, could help convince voters that his is the best environmental and fiscal choice, he hopes. Though it takes millions to fund an ecological park, he says the town can obtain money from Corporate and foundation grants. |